A film buff's quest to view all the films on They Shoot Pictures, Don't They's 1,000 Greatest Films list (www.theyshootpictures.com/gf1000)
Tuesday, January 18, 2011
#293: All About My Mother
Directed by: PEDRO ALMODOVAR
1999, TSPDT Rank #678
This post contains content written for the Internet Film Club.
I didn't feel this film was quite as good as Talk to Her. I felt that it was lacking in emotional depth. That being said, it is still a very good film, and I feel that as far as the screenplay goes, the overall content is better than in Talk to Her. Talk to Her is much more emotion centered, and All About My Mother is much more plot and character oriented. If there would have been more emotional depth to back up the melodrama (especially toward the end) this would really have been a knockout film. But at this point as far as saying which of the two I liked better, I would say that's pretty much an apples and oranges question, because I have different reasons for liking the different films. I think they're both about the same general quality, so I'll give the same rating to both.
I have been an avid film buff since early middle school, and started a blog charting my progress on the 1,000 Greatest Films list from They Shoot Pictures, Don't They? during high school as an offshoot of my writing for an internet film club that I belong to. Now I am a college graduate living in Japan - and I decided to keep my blog going for the fun of it.